I think it’s safe to say that “classroom management” is a big deal in teaching. Not much learning can happen if students are running wild in a classroom. Schools of education have been criticized for not preparing teacher candidates enough in the area of classroom management, and there is a movement in some charter networks to focus almost exclusively on classroom management. While there’s some valid reason for the criticism and the resulting craze, I want to take apart what we really mean when we refer to classroom management.
1. The use of the word “management” in the first place is kind of a misnomer. What we are really talking about is a teacher’s leadership of his or her students. (This was first pointed out to me by my mentor, Madeleine Ray, faculty at Bank Street College of Education.)
2. “Management” of students cannot be separated from all of the other aspects of teaching.
The first question might be “who is the leader in this classroom?” If the teacher is not the leader, then there’s a leadership crises to address, which is no small task. We might ask, which student(s) are trying to lead? What’s their agenda? What do they offer that the teacher currently doesn’t? What are the problems with this balance of power? Or maybe the teacher is the clear leader, but he or she is, say, leaving students vulnerable on certain fronts or leading in a direction that works for only some students. Then there are leadership issues to tackle, none of which are superficial.
Somehow, we understand that leadership runs deep. It’s personal, and it’s about courage, vision, and follow-through. While there are techniques to learn when it comes to managing AND leading a classroom of students, let’s not pretend the leadership (or “classroom management”) aspect of teaching can be condensed into a simple checklist of actions that works the same with every group. People and group dynamics have always been and will always be more complex than that.
Share this post:
Author
Ariel Sacks
Ariel Sacks began her 13-year teaching career in New York City public schools after earning her master’s degree at Bank Street College and has taught and coached in grades 7-9. She is the author of Whole Novels for the Whole Class: A Student Centered Approach (Jossey-Bass, 2014) and writes a teaching column for Education Week Teacher.
Ariel’s work as a teacher leader with the Center for Teaching Quality involved her in co-authoring Teaching 2030: What We Must Do For Our Public Schools – Now and in the Future. She was also featured in the CTQ book Teacherpreneurs: Innovative Teachers Who Lead Without Leaving.
She is currently working on a book about the role of creative writing in equitable, 21st century schools, and she speaks and leads workshops on the whole novels approach.
Related Posts
September 13, 2021
Pause, ponder, then plan:
Cultivating Communities of Impact
February 23, 2021