If you spend any time in Twitter, it would have been impossible to miss the whirlwind created earlier this week when Education Next released their list of the “Top 25 Educator Tweeters.”
In a nod to inevitability, Education Next stumbled into an argument over who the REAL thought leaders are in the educational conversations that are taking place online.
Comment sections and Twitter conversations were full of plugs for people who were left off the list, questions about who exactly some of the people on the list were and criticisms of the metrics used to judge influence in online spaces.
The real lesson here is a simple one, y’all: It’s impossible to develop a SINGLE list of influencers because digital spaces allow us to join together in customized groups with people studying the topics that WE care the most about.
Translation: The list of the “Top 25 Educator Tweeters” I generate might be completely different than the list that you generate—and that’s EXACTLY how it should be!
Social media spaces allow you to network with people who share YOUR passion—and as long as you’re reaching out to influence—and to be influenced by—others, you will learn more no matter what your Klout score is.
Want to know who is influencing my thinking a ton right now?
Chris Wejr is pushing my thinking about honors assemblies.
Want to know what they all have in common?
They are all thinking and sharing about the topics that I’m most interested in at the current moment.
Translation: My grading practices aren’t very progressive, I’m sad that some kids get recognized more than others in schools, I know just how important effective leadership is to success, and I think teachers need to understand how current policies are destroying our profession.
That makes Russ, Matt, Paul, Chris, Justin, Bo, David, Nancy and Alice PERFECT follows for me right now. They are openly sharing provocative thoughts about their personal interests that are challenging me right now.
Does that make them “good follows” for you?
Only if you, too, stink at grading, run horrible honors assemblies, need to know more about effective school leadership and feel like fighting back against piss-poor educational policy.
Does that mean that Russ and Matt and Paul and Chris and Justin and Bo and David and Nancy and Alice will ALWAYS be the “Top Education Tweeters” in my PLN?
Probably not. I mean, the odds are that my interests will change over time—and when they do, I’ll work to find other bright minds that can challenge me.
And while I’ll always stay connected to these guys—lots of meaningful interactions over time has made each more of a friend than an avatar in my Twitterstream—they might be dropped from my list of “Top Tweeters,” however hurtful that may be.
Long story short: Influence is personal—customized by your current circumstances, interests and preferences.
Just like the most effective PLNs.
Related Radical Reads: