A Parent’s Reflection on School Letter Grades

Last week, I made the argument that North Carolina’s decision to assign letter grades to individual schools based on nothing more than test scores on final exams was a form of institutional racism that harms communities of poverty and strips support away from the public school system.  I was writing as an advocate for public schools and poor communities — two causes that I feel are under attack by our state’s super conservative legislature.

But I’m not JUST an advocate for public schools and poor communities any more.  I am also the parent of a second grade daughter who attends a public school.  So crappy choices made by our legislators hurt MY kid.  This issue is personal.

My daughter’s school is nothing short of a remarkable place.  EVERY time that I stop by, I feel a sense of happiness from everyone that I meet.  Students smile and skip and laugh and joke with each other and with their teachers.  Teachers are relaxed and joyful, invested in each other and in their students.  Provocative questions are being asked and answered, positive messages are being shared in conversations and in school-wide displays, and programs that concentrate on developing the whole child — from daily Spanish instruction for every student to rich music and art experiences that are valued equally alongside more traditional content-specific subjects — are a priority.

The community overwhelmingly supports my daughter’s school.  Thousands of parents and children turn out for after school events — whether they be teacher talent shows, campus beautification projects, or annual 5K run walks — to work, to play and to celebrate with one another.  Each of these events is a reminder that our school isn’t just a place of learning — it’s a place to belong.  Lots of schools like to talk about being a family.  My daughter’s school actually FEELS like a family.


But they were rated a C — which means something akin to “decidedly average” — by the State of North Carolina last week.  And that has me worried.

Now don’t get me wrong:  I’m not worried about the current quality of the education that my daughter’s getting.  I’ve seen the impact that the people in her building have had on her.  She is LOVED by darn near everyone and she knows it.  She is learning the kinds of academic and social skills that I want her to learn in a place where learning really IS seen as a joyful act worthy of celebration.   She has role models to look up to who challenge her to be better than who she is — and I am convinced that those role models see her as something much more than just a test score.

What I am worried about is the consequences that a C rating will have on the choices that her teachers make.

My guess is that it has been a stressful beginning of the school year for everyone at my daughter’s school.  In a district that takes a lot of pride from having top “performing” students (read: really high test scores), being rated a C is guaranteed to leave everyone rattled and questioning their practices.  There have probably been some serious conversations about changes that have to be made to get those test scores up for next year — and there is probably external pressure coming from folks in the district office to find solutions so that “this kind of thing doesn’t happen again.”

And there’s NO doubt that those “solutions” are going to strip away some of what makes my daughter’s school such an unique place.  Questions will probably be asked about the value of daily Spanish instruction in a building with low test scores.  Wouldn’t that time or those dollars be better spent on another reading interventionist?  There will probably be more benchmark testing and more students pulled out of specials or out of the regular classroom in order to make sure that they are “progressing enough” to “produce better results” on next year’s end of grade exams.

Her teachers — particularly those with the lowest test scores — are less likely to run with moments of inspiration in the classroom.  After all, student curiosity is messy and time consuming.  Increasing test scores depends on efficiency and focus.  Worse yet, her teachers are more likely to see kids like my daughter — who ISN’T a strong reader — as a frustrating liability instead of as a quirky ball of happy energy.  Why would you celebrate uniqueness when standardized outcomes are the only outcomes valued by the people governing your schools?

There’s even a good chance that these changes — increased stress and pressure, fewer opportunities to celebrate curiosity, shifts away from valuing the whole child to valuing the parts of a child that actually impact a school’s “measurable results” — will drive some of the best teachers away from my daughter’s school. Once you’ve had the chance to work in a place where joyful learning is a priority, it’s hard to see that priority erased in favor of chasing higher test scores.

My only hope is that the teachers of my daughter’s school will realize just HOW important — and HOW valued — their work really is.

There is NOTHING “decidedly average” about the learning space that they have created.  Children feel loved, parents feel welcomed, and students are learning WAY more than a single C rating based on nothing more than standardized tests could ever possibly communicate.  In my book — filled with experiences as a teacher and a professional developer in probably close to 100 schools in dozens of states and several different countries — they are a solid A.  I’d work there in a minute.

But more importantly, I’d send my daughter there for the rest of her school career without any reservation, convinced that she’d be a better person as a result of the care and attention of the teachers that she had a chance to learn from.



Related Radical Reads:

Are School Letter Grades a Form of Institutional Racism?

Are Grades Destroying My Six Year Old Kid?

Learning > Schooling


    While I do believe that a

    While I do believe that a school should be held accountable for students’ learning, It truly pains me to see a school is judged solely based on a letter grade.  Yes, I have seen other schools like your school that have received an average letter grade and when that happens everyone is on panic.  That, of course, takes away the joy of teaching and learning.  

  • KileyJackson

    Couldn’t agree more

    Bill –  

            You could not be more spot on with how teachers will react when their school is rated as average. I am a teacher in Kansas and this breaks my heart to hear how amazing you feel about your daughter’s school and teachers. More and more pressure is building each school because of the standarized tests our students take. There are teachers who are leaving the profession because they are demanded to teach only what is on the standarized test. Other than seeing how a school peforms, these tests do not mean anything for to the child. They are not used to see if they can get into college, technical school, or a community college. I think it is important for teachers to teach more than the state standards. Being a good person and contributing to society is just as important as knowing how to read and complete math problems. I think parents like you are amazing. Keep telling your daughter’s teachers how amazing they are and do it publicly. Hopefully more parents will follow in your footsteps and administration will concetrate more on the positives of what is happening in the classrooms than on standarized tests.

  • Jenifer_Roberts


    It is good for the students that parent’s reflection is on the children’s and they will do the same things like their parents which is good for them and they can do their best in their education life do my assignment uk.

  • sunnysharma

    free playstation codes

    Have you heard that you can crack the playstation store for download the games from it.My indirect mean is that you can get by through free playstation plus codes-psn code generator 2016 .This is the free psn codes which makes you achieve the unlimited access into the playstations store.

  • AnneJolly

    It’s a needed approach

    Grades, grades, grades.  If we’re going to give a child or a teacher or a school a “grade” then we have to be prepared to live with the consequences – we will work on getting better at whatever is being graded.

    What about “mastery” being a grade? What are schools and teachers “mastering?” (Not to mention kids.)  I doubt if test scores is considered a quality skill for mastery.  And what about things that can’t be as easily tested, such as innovation, curiosity and ethics? We’ve somehow failed to “grow” our education system to keep pace with with the needs of a rapidly changing society.  How long before we can figure out a way to learn, grow, and change as an educational system?